Domesticating a foreign judgment in Florida refers to the legal process of recognizing and enforcing a court judgment from another state within the Florida court system. This procedure is essential for creditors who wish to enforce a judgment against a debtor who has assets in Florida. The process involves submitting the original judgment to a Florida court, granting it the same authority and enforceability as a judgment originally issued in Florida.
What Law Allows a Creditor to Domesticate a Foreign Judgment?
Domestication of foreign judgments in Florida is governed by the Florida Enforcement of Foreign Judgments Act, which aligns with the Uniform Enforcement of Foreign Judgments Act adopted by many states. In Florida, this is found in sections 55.503 and 55.505 of the Florida Statutes.
This Act outlines the specific procedures and requirements for recognizing and enforcing out-of-state judgments, ensuring consistency and fairness in the process.
What Are the Steps to Domesticate a Foreign Judgment in Florida?
Here’s an overview of this process:
1. Obtain a Certified Copy of the Foreign Judgment: The first step is to acquire a certified copy of the judgment from the clerk of the court in the state where the judgment was originally entered. This document must be an official and authenticated record.
2. File the Judgment with a Florida Court: The certified copy of the judgment must then be filed with the clerk of the circuit court in the Florida county where the creditor seeks to enforce the judgment. There is typically a filing fee associated with this step.
3. Provide Notice to the Debtor: Florida law requires that the debtor be notified after filing the judgment. The creditor must serve the debtor with a copy of the filed judgment and an affidavit. The affidavit usually includes details about the judgment, the last known address of the debtor, and a statement that the judgment is valid and enforceable.
4. Wait for the Mandatory Waiting Period: Florida law imposes a 30-day waiting period from when the debtor is served with the notice. During this time, the debtor can contest the domestication of the judgment. This contest is typically based on jurisdictional issues or claims that the original judgment was obtained fraudulently.
5. Address Any Challenges by the Debtor: If the debtor challenges domestication, the court will address these challenges. Common grounds for contesting include arguing that the original court lacked jurisdiction or that the judgment is not final or is on appeal. The debtor cannot, however, re-litigate the merits of the case.
6. Enforcement of the Judgment: If there are no successful challenges by the debtor, or once any challenges are resolved, the foreign judgment is considered domesticated in Florida. The judgment is then treated as though it were originally issued by a Florida court and can be enforced accordingly. Enforcement actions can include garnishing wages, levying bank accounts, or placing liens on property.
7. Periodic Renewal (if necessary): Depending on the time elapsed, it might be necessary to renew the judgment in Florida to keep it enforceable, as judgments can expire after a certain period.
Defenses to Domesticating a Foreign Judgment in Florida
Judgment debtors can try to defend against the domestication of a foreign judgment based on Florida law. Here are the main defenses:
- Lack of Jurisdiction: One of the primary defenses is arguing that the original court did not have proper jurisdiction over the case or the defendant. This could mean that the court lacked personal jurisdiction (the authority to make decisions affecting the defendant) or subject matter jurisdiction (the authority to hear the type of case presented).
- Improper Service of Process: The defense may assert that the defendant was not properly served with the lawsuit documents in the original case. Proper service is a critical requirement for due process, and failure to serve the defendant correctly can render the judgment invalid.
- Fraud in Obtaining the Judgment: If the judgment was obtained through fraudulent means, such as presenting false information or misleading the court, this could be a basis for challenging the domestication of the judgment in Florida.
- Expiration of the Judgment: If the judgment is too old, it might not be enforceable. Different states have varying statutes of limitations for how long a judgment remains valid. The judgment cannot be domesticated or enforced if this time has elapsed.
- Violation of Due Process: A defense may be raised on the grounds that the original proceedings violated the defendant’s due process rights. This could involve issues like insufficient notice of the lawsuit or an opportunity to be heard in court.
- Pending Appeal or Modification: If the judgment is under appeal or being modified in the state where it was issued, it cannot be domesticated in Florida until the appeal or modification process is complete.
- Bankruptcy of the Debtor: If the debtor has filed for bankruptcy, this may halt the domestication process. An automatic stay in bankruptcy typically stops all collection activities, including domestication of judgments.
- Substantive Errors in the Original Judgment: While generally, the merits of the case cannot be re-litigated during the domestication process, if there were significant substantive errors in the original judgment, this might be a basis for challenge.
- The Judgment Contravenes Florida Public Policy: If the judgment involves matters contrary to Florida’s public policy, the courts in Florida may refuse to domesticate it.
- Satisfaction of the Judgment: If the judgment has already been paid or otherwise satisfied, this can be used as a defense against domestication.
How Long Does a Creditor Have to Domesticate a Foreign Judgment?
In Florida, the timeframe within which a creditor can domesticate a foreign judgment is governed by the statute of limitations. The key factor to consider is the foreign judgment’s lifespan according to the state’s laws where it was issued.
Generally, Florida law recognizes the principle of giving full faith and credit to judgments from other states, as mandated by the U.S. Constitution. This means that as long as the foreign judgment is valid and enforceable in the state where it was issued, it can typically be domesticated in Florida.
However, specifics can vary. Most states, including Florida, have a statute of limitations for enforcing judgments that usually ranges from 5 to 20 years, and this period can often be renewed. Therefore, a creditor must domesticate the foreign judgment in Florida within this period.
For example, if a judgment has a 10-year enforceability period in the state where it was issued, the creditor would generally need to domesticate that judgment in Florida within that 10-year timeframe. If the statute of limitations on the judgment is close to expiring, the creditor may need to renew the judgment in the original state before domesticating it in Florida.
Once domesticated in Florida, the judgment will be subject to Florida’s statute of limitations for enforcement. In Florida, a domesticated foreign judgment is treated as a Florida judgment, which typically has a 20-year lifespan but can vary depending on the specific type of judgment and any applicable renewals.
Sign up for the latest articles.
Get regular updates from our blog, where we discuss asset protection techniques and answer common questions.