|
BANKRUPTCY - Chapter
7
Introduction
The information contained
herein is specific to cases filed in the Middle District of
Florida, Orlando Division and reflect the experiences of this
attorney. This basic information about Chapter 7 bankruptcy
should assist you in understanding the course of events that
occur when you file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy. If you cannot
find the answer to your question here, you may e-mail your questions
to your bankruptcy attorney. This website information
does not replace or modify any separate written agreement with
or written information provided to clients of Jonathan Alper,
PLC.
The New
Bankruptcy Law
The new bankruptcy
law (effective October 17, 2005) makes filing bankruptcy more
complicated. The new law is accompanied by new rules,
new forms, and additional work for debtors and their attorneys.
Additionally, there are many parts of the new law which are
ambiguous and subject to multiple interpretations. As
judges interpret and clarify the new bankruptcy law through
court decisions, the new law will become more clear. Since
bankruptcy courts are located all over the country, even if
one judge interprets a part of the new law, it will take time
for that interpretation to be tested on appeal and for the ultimate
ruling to spread throughout the country's legal community.
Your bankruptcy attorney will try to advise you as best as (s)he
can about the effect of the new law on your situation.
There is some uncertainty about how the new bankruptcy law may
impact your bankruptcy case.
Filing
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy in Florida
A permanent resident of Florida can
file bankruptcy in a Florida bankruptcy court. Florida has three
bankruptcy districts (Southern District, Middle District, and
Northern District), and each of Florida’s counties is
assigned to one of the three bankruptcy districts. You must
file bankruptcy in the district where you reside.
An important concept in both Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcy
is “exemptions” or “exempt property.”
When you file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the Trustee takes all
of your “non-exempt” property and sells it for the
benefit of your unsecured creditors. The Trustee cannot take
your exempt property and you may keep all of your exempt property
regardless of its value and amount. What property is “exempt”
and what property is “non-exempt” depends on the
exemption laws of the applicable state. Each state has its own
and different laws about what assets are exempt and non-exempt
for bankruptcy purposes. Therefore, before you file bankruptcy
you and your bankruptcy attorney must ascertain which state
laws will determine your exempt assets.
Florida has liberal bankruptcy exemptions for some assets, including
an unlimited homestead exemption in most cases, and limited
exemptions for other assets. Only Florida residents are eligible
for Florida exemptions. Just because you are a Florida resident
when you file for bankruptcy does not mean you are entitled
to Florida exemptions in bankruptcy.
Under the new bankruptcy law the state exemption law applicable
to your bankruptcy is determined by the state in which you have
been domiciled for the 730 days (two years) immediately preceding
your filing date. If you have not been a permanent resident
of Florida for the two-year period immediately preceding your
bankruptcy, then your bankruptcy exemptions will be those allowed
by the state in which you were domiciled for 180 days immediately
preceding the two year period, or the state in which you were
domiciled for the longer portion of such 180-day period.
Otherwise stated, a person filing bankruptcy in Florida today
is eligible for the property exemptions he could have claimed
if he had filed two years ago. If this person was a Florida
resident two years ago he claims Florida exemptions today;
if two years ago he was a resident of a different state then
he is entitled to the exemptions of the state of his prior residence.
| Consider a person who sells his residence
in Georgia for $100,000 and moves to Florida in January.
In March of that year he purchases a Florida homestead for
$100,000. The person gets a Florida drivers license and
registers to vote in Florida. In March of the following
year, 14 months after becoming a Florida resident, the same
person loses his job and files bankruptcy. Under the new
bankruptcy law, Georgia’s relatively limited exemption
laws would apply to this bankruptcy, and the debtor would
not have the benefit of Florida homestead protection. |
In reality, the laws about bankruptcy exemptions are even more
complicated than the example above. Many issues are unclear
in the new law and will have to be resolved over time through
court decisions. Before you file bankruptcy in Florida you and
your bankruptcy attorney should discuss where you have resided
during the past few years and should discuss whether Florida
bankruptcy exemptions would apply in your case. In many cases,
the state where you moved from will provide better bankruptcy
exemptions than will Florida law.
Exempt
and Non-Exempt Property in Florida
If Florida exemption
law applies to your bankruptcy, the following are the principle
bankruptcy exemptions under Florida law.
Exempt
Property
1. Homestead.
Your homestead is exempt property under Article X, Section 4
of the Florida Constitution. This protection is afforded homestead
properties situated on one-half acre or less within a municipality
and properties up to 160 acres outside a municipality. There
is no dollar limitation. The homestead exemption applies to
all Florida residents. The new bankruptcy law does not affect
homestead protection for Florida residents in state court proceedings.
The new bankruptcy law does change the homestead exemption for
Florida residents who file bankruptcy. Under the new law you
can protect unlimited equity in your homestead provided you
purchased the residence 40 months or more prior to filing bankruptcy.
If you purchased your home within 40 months the new law exempts
up to $137,000 of equity. The exemption amount is increased
(effective April, 2007) from the original $125,000 to approximatley
$137,000 per person. Additionally, if you injected cash in your
home within the 40 months, such as by paying down the mortgage
or building a home addition, the amount of investment made within
the 40 months will not be exempt even if you purchased the home
40 months prior to filing. The $137,000 homestead exemption
limit applies only in bankruptcy cases. Several courts have
held that a married couple filing jointly can claim two homestead
exemptions for a total homestead protection of $274,000.
2. Statutory Exemptions Chapter 222 of the Florida Statutes
includes several categories of exempt property, including: pensions,
401K plans, tax deferred retirement plans, Social Security income,
disability income, IRAs, annuities, cash value of life insurance,
college investment plans (including 529 Plans), health savings
accounts, and hurricane savings accounts.
3. Automobile Exemption: You are allowed to exempt $1,000
of equity in an automobile. Spouses who jointly own a car may
exempt $2,000 of value in that car. Most bankruptcy trustees
accept the average retail/wholesale value from the yellow NADA
book, adjusted for the condition of your car. If the balance
of your car loan is greater than the car value (“upside
down”) then you have no car equity and your car is protected
in bankruptcy so long as you keep your car payments current.
4. Miscellaneous personal property exemption. Each bankruptcy
debtor is allowed to exempt $1,000 ($2,000 for joint filings)
of all other personal property including furniture, cloths,
tools, and estimated cash on hand. For bankruptcy purposes the
value of your personal property is its current fair market value
at a public market such as a garage sale or flea market sale.
A new Florida statute effective July 1, 2007, provides a $4,000 "wildcard"
personal property exemption to bankruptcy debtors who do not
claim a homestead exemption. You must not own a home or intend to surrender the home you do own to the mortgage lender in order to qualifiy for the wildcard exemption. Joint debtors can claim a $8,000 wildcard exemption.
You meet a bankruptcy trustee after you file bankruptcy. The trustee has 30 days following your meeting to object to your exemptions. If you claim an asset as exempt on your bankruptcy petition and there is no objection within 30 days after your trustee meeting you may assume the asset is exempt and you may do whatever you want with that asset.
Non-Exempt
Property
Any property which
is not exempt under Florida law is included in the bankruptcy
estate. The Chapter 7 Trustee may take and sell all non-exempt
property and distribute the proceeds to the unsecured creditors.
(You will have the opportunity to keep your non-exempt property
by entering into a "buy-back" agreement with the Trustee.
If you execute a buy-back agreement with the Trustee, you will
make either a lump sum payment to the Trustee or make monthly
installment payments over a period of several months.)
Credit Counseling
The new bankruptcy law requires that anyone who files bankruptcy
must received credit counseling and financial education by approved
providers as a condition for filing bankruptcy and discharging
debts. No one can file bankruptcy unless they complete accredited
credit counseling within 180 days of their bankruptcy filings.
You will not get your bankruptcy discharge unless you complete the financial management class after you file your peitition. The credit counseling can be provided in person, by telephone
conference, or over the internet. Most courses take less than one hour. You have to pay for credit
counseling, but the costs are regulated. Most courses cost less than $40. You will be required to file a certificate
from the credit counseling agency verifying the course completion
with your bankruptcy petition. If credit counseling resulted
in a debt repayment plan, you must file a copy of the plan.
Your bankruptcy attorney can tell you where to find approved
credit counseling providers.
In addition, during the course of your bankruptcy you must also
complete an instruction course concerning personal financial
management in order to have your debts legally discharged. As
is the case with credit counseling, financial management courses
may be provided by phone or on line. You are responsible to pay credit counseling fees. Your bankruptcy attorney can tell you where
to find approved financial management providers.
Eligibility For Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
Under the old bankruptcy law almost any resident of the United
States could file Chapter 7 bankruptcy. The new bankruptcy law
includes a two part test of Chapter 7 eligibility. The first test applicable in every Chapter 7 filing is the "means test." The means tes is a mathematical formula to
determine who may (and who may not) be eligible to file Chapter
7 bankruptcy. The means test applies only to people whose debts
are primarily consumer debts. Consumer debtors include credit
card debts, car debt, or mortgages for the primary residence.
Many people are forced into bankruptcy because of non-consumer
debt such as debts from a failed business, large business related
judgment or delinquent mortgages on investment real estate.
Those people whose debts are primarily business or investment
debts, or debtors who owe primarilty other non-consumer debts
such as taxes or student loans, are exempt from the means test;
these people may file Chapter 7 bankruptcy regardless of their
income and expenses. Most importantly, if your family income
is less than the median income for similarly sized Florida households
you too are exempt from the means test. As of October, 2008, the Florida median income
for a two-person household is approximately $52,000. The median income for a single person is approximately $41,000.
The means test formula is designed to evaluate whether the debtor
has the financial means to pay back a substantial part of his
debts in a repayment plan through Chapter 13 bankruptcy. The
means test formula considers measures of income and allowable
expenses. If, according to results of the formula, you do not
have sufficient net monthly income to repay debts you are eligible
to file Chapter 7; if the formula says you can repay your debts
you are not eligible for Chapter 7 bankruptcy unless you prove
"special circumstances" of hardship such as a recent
job loss or medical problem. You may be eligible for relief
in Chapter 13 bankruptcy.
The means test formula is very complex and several
of its important terms are counter-intuitive. The formula incorporates
a variety of government statistics from several sources as well
as information about each debtor’s financial situation.
Calculations under the formula are difficult to do without a
professional computer program designed for bankruptcy attorneys
to prepare bankruptcy petitions.
Passing the means test creates a presumption of eligibility to file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, but the means test is not the only test applicable to Chapter 7 eligibility. The new bankruptcy law includes a secondary test under Section 707(b) known as the "good faith" or "abuse" test. The United States Trustee, or any other party in your case, can request the Court dismiss your Chapter 7 filing if it appears that the filing was done in "bad faith" or was otherwise an "abuse" of the bankurptcy system. This test is applicable only in those cases when the U.S. Trustee or other party files a motion to dismiss under the applicable Code section. If in the light of all relevant financial and family circumstances it appears that you have the ability to repay a significant amount of your unsecured debts a Court could dismiss your Chapter 7 if the filing appears to be abusive. Whereas the "means test" is mostly a objective mathematical computation, the "abuse" test is subjective. Therefore, it is difficult to predict with certainty whether debtors above median income can survive allegations of bankruptcy abuse under Section 707(b). Different court decisions have expressed a variety of facts and circumstances relevant to findings of abusive Chapter 7 cases.
You may not obtain a discharge in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy within 8 years of the filing date of a previous bankruptcy in which you received a Chapter 7 discharge- the prohibition is 8 years from the prior filing date rather than the prior discharge. There is a 6 year wait after a prior Chapter 13 discharge. Thus, a debtor may obtain a discharge in a new Chapter 7 cases as long as 6 years have passed since the filing of a prior Chapter 13 chase in which a discharge had been granted. In addition, there is no time restriction on obtaining a discharge in a new chapter 7 chase after a prior Chapter 13 case in which a discharge was granted if 100% of the allowed unsecured claims where paid, or in which the actual payments under the previous Chapter 13 plan comprised at leas 70% of the allowed unsecured claims in that case.
A summary of the means test and its most important terms and
definitions is provided in the bankruptcy section elsewhere
on this website.
Basic Bankruptcy Information
Secured
or Unsecured Debts. The bankruptcy petition asks you
to list secured debts separately from unsecured debts.
Unsecured debts include personal loans and credit
cards issued by banks, such as Visa, MasterCard, American
Express, or Discover, and other credit cards used to purchase
consumable items. Vehicle leases are unsecured debts. Medical
bills and personal loans are also unsecured debts.
Secured debts include those debts where the creditor
has a security interest in your property to guarantee payment.
Examples of secured debts include mortgages, car loan, loans
from finance companies (usually secured by household items),
furniture, computers or electronics. If you purchased store
goods using a store credit card, such as a card from Circuit
City, Rooms to Go, Best Buy, Rhodes, etc., the store probably
has a security interest in certain items purchased, which
makes the store a secured creditor.
Secured Property. After filing a
Chapter 7 bankruptcy, you will have to choose to either reaffirm
secured debts or surrender the secured items to the creditor.
You are entitled to keep any secured property as long as you
continue to pay the loan for that property. If, however, you
elect to surrender secured property, the secured creditor may
not thereafter recover any money from you personally on account
of that debt. Some mortgage companies recently have required
borrowers to sign cross-collateralization agreements by which
the mortgage borrowers pledge bank accounts and other financial
instruments to secure their mortgage. A cross-collateralization
clause allows the mortgage lender to get money in your financial
accounts to pay delinquent mortgage payments. If you are unsure
whether you pledged financial accounts to your mortgage
lender you should review the papers you signed when you got
your mortgage.
Reaffirmation
Agreements. The bankruptcy law requires you to execute a reaffirmation
agreement for secured personal property you want to keep after the bankruptcy. The bankruptcy judges in the Orlando Division also require debtors to reaffirm mortgages on land, or alternatively, surrender the property to the mortgage lender. If you surrender property during a bankruptcy you will have not further liability under that loan.
You
must sign a reaffirmation agreement for all secured property you want to retain within 45 days of the first
meeting with the trustee (the meeting of creditors or 341 meeting).
If you do not sign the reaffirmation agreement or redeem the
property within 45 days, the automatic stay is lifted as to
that property and the creditor is permitted to take all legal
action allowable under the law to repossess or foreclose the property (if
payments are not current). Signing a reaffirmation agreement
means that you will be personally liable to pay the debts after
your bankruptcy is over. You do not have the unlimited right
to reaffirm a debt. Your attorney must sign your reaffirmation
agreement if he believes you can afford the debt. If the attorney
is not sure you can afford reaffirmation, the attorney may choose
not to sign your reaffirmation agreement. In that event, you
must file with the bankruptcy court a Reaffirmation Agreement Explanation form showing why you think you have the financial ability to pay a reaffirmed debt. The bankruptcy judge will review your explanation and either deny or approve the reaffirmation. If the reaffirmation is denied you still may be able to keep your property if payments are current, or you could request a hearing with the judge. If the court refuses to approve your reaffirmation many creditors will let you keep your property if maintain current payments.
Redemption. Bankruptcy also gives
you the option to “redeem” secured personal property
such as furniture, computers, automobiles, or other property
purchased on credit and subject to a lien in favor of the lender.
Redemption means purchasing the property from the secured lender
at its current retail market value considering its age and condition.
When the current retail value is less than the amount due under the loan, redemption can be financially beneficial.
Student Loans. Student loans are not
dischargeable unless you can show that your loan payments impose
“undue hardship.” In order to eliminate your student
loans under the “undue hardship exception” you must
file a separate motion with the bankruptcy court, and you must
appear before the bankruptcy judge with proof of your hardship.
As a practical matter, it is very difficult to demonstrate undue
hardship unless you are physically unable to work.
Procedure
Before Filing
Unfair Debt Collection. The Federal
Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (the “Act”) prohibits
unfair collection of consumer debts. If you can prove that your
creditors intentionally and repeatedly violated the Act before
or after you retained your bankruptcy attorney, you may be able
to recover damages. The following is a summary of a few prohibited
debt collection practices:
1. Calling you before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. local time.
2. Contacting you directly after you told the creditor you retained
me to represent you.
3. Telling your employer or co-worker that you owe money to
the creditor.
4. Calling you at work after you have told them not to.
5. Intentional and continuous harassment or abuse in connection
with a debt.
6. A creditor’s representative falsely representing that
he is an attorney when in fact he is not licensed to practice
law.
7. Threatening you with arrest or imprisonment for failing to
pay a debt.
8. Communicating with anyone other than you our your spouse
about your debt.
The debt collection laws are complicated, and your right to
recovery will depend on your specific facts and your evidence.
Contact your bankruptcy attorney if you believe you can prove
one of your creditors intentionally and repeatedly engaged in
unfair collection practices. A copy of the complete Act is available
at http://www.ftc.gov under
Consumer Information.
Use of Credit Cards. Do not use any
credit cards after our initial consultation with your bankruptcy
attorney or once you have decided to file bankruptcy.
If you have charges or cash advances in the months preceding
filing bankruptcy, the creditor may file an adversary complaint
alleging that you incurred recent charges with fraudulent intent
and without the intent and/or ability to repay these debts.
Credit Union Loans. Many credit unions
will make you close your checking and savings accounts if you
discharge a loan or credit card debt from the same credit union.
In such event, you will have to open new checking and savings
accounts at a different financial institution. Additionally,
your credit union loan may be secured by funds in your credit
union accounts, and in such event, the credit union can seize
money in these accounts to pay the loan prior to the filing
of the bankruptcy petition. You should examine your loan documents
or talk to your credit union if you are unsure whether or not
your credit union loan is secured by money in the accounts.
Many credit unions also “cross-collateralize” loans,
which means that a credit card account may be secured by other
property such as your automobiles.
Get a Credit Report. You must obtain
a credit report and furnish a copy to our office prior to filing
bankruptcy. If you have recently been denied credit, you are
entitled to a free credit report from the reporting agency.
Instructions for obtaining this report should be on the letter
you received denying credit. Also, a recent federal law gives
you the right to obtain a free credit report once a year. You
can obtain a free credit report from one or all of the primary
credit reporting agencies at http://www.annualcreditreport.com.
The Automatic Stay. The automatic
stay acts like a shield between you and your creditors by prohibiting
the commencement or continuation of creditors’ judicial
proceedings against you as well as all collection efforts. The
automatic stay does not begin when you hire a bankruptcy attorney,
but begins only after you file your bankruptcy petition.
Limits on Automatic Stay in Subsequent Bankruptcy.
If you file a bankruptcy petition under Chapter 7 or Chapter
13 within one (1) year of the dismissal of an earlier case,
the automatic stay in the second case terminates thirty (30)
days after the second bankruptcy unless you demonstrate that
the second bankruptcy was filed in good faith with respect to
the creditor sought to be stayed. A second repeat bankruptcy
filing within the same one (1) year period will not effect the
automatic stay.
Attorney Certifications.
The new bankruptcy
law places additional duties on bankruptcy attorneys representing
debtors in Chapter 7 bankruptcy cases. Your bankruptcy attorney
must certify to the court that he or she has performed a reasonable
investigation into circumstances giving rise to your bankruptcy,
that your bankruptcy petition is well-grounded in fact, and
the attorney has determined that your bankruptcy does not constitute
an abusive filing. Also, the bankruptcy attorney must certify
that, after reasonable inquiry, he or she has no knowledge that
the information in your bankruptcy schedules is incorrect. These
requirements increase the attorney’s duties and liability.
Your bankruptcy lawyer may ask you to provide copies of your
pay stubs, checking account statements, credit reports and certain
other information about your finances and assets.
Information About Your Case
If you want information
about your case after filing, including your case number, meeting
date with the trustee, discharge date etc., you should call
the Bankruptcy Court’s automatic information system at
1-866-879-1286.
Trustee
Meeting After Filing the Petition
Notice
of Meeting of Creditors. When the petition is filed,
a combined Order Scheduling a Meeting of Creditors and Fixing
Filing Dates for Claims, Complaints Objecting to Discharge,
and Complaints Seeking Exception to Discharge will be sent by
the Court to all creditors, to you, and to your attorney's office.
This is commonly referred to as the “341 Notice”
or the “Creditor Meeting Notice.” You should receive
this Notice from the bankruptcy court approximately ten (10)
days after your petition is filed.
What is a Trustee and What Does He/She Do? The “Bankrupt
Estate” consists of all legal and equitable interests
you have in property as of the date the case is filed. In Chapter
7 one primary job of the Trustee is to gather all of your non-exempt
assets, sell those assets, and distribute the proceeds among
all your unsecured creditors. A Trustee is randomly appointed
by the Court immediately upon the filing of a Chapter 7 petition.
The Trustee is usually a private attorney or CPA, and he is compensated
primarily by a percentage of the non-exempt assets he or she
is able to collect and distribute to your creditors
Meeting with Trustee. In the Middle
District of Florida - Orlando Division, the meeting with your
Chapter 7 trustee (the “creditors meeting” or “341
meeting”) is held in a conference room, not the courtroom,
and the federal bankruptcy judge is prohibited by law from being
there. Typically this meeting will last about ten minutes. The
trustee will ask you questions about your banrkuptcy petition.
Your bankruptcy attorney can tell you what questions to anticipate.
The U.S. Trustee ( a different trustee) sometimes attends these meetings to discuss issues with your means test computation.
Who attends? You are required to attend
the creditors meeting with the bankruptcy trustee (if filing
jointly, both husband and wife must attend). Your bankruptcy
attorney will accompany you and represent you at the meeting.
As a practical matter very few, if any, unsecured creditors
attend. The trustee's job is to represent all creditors whether
or not a creditor attends the meeting of creditors.
What Happens at the Creditors Meeting?
The Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Trustee will ask you questions, but
(s)he will not interrogate you, cross-examine you, or threaten
you. The trustee may ask you why you filed bankruptcy. The trustee
often asks questions about your assets and your sources of income. The trustee often will inquire about entries and answers on your bankruptcy petition. As stated above, the U.S. Trustee may ask questions about your income and expenses to make sure you qualify for Chapter 7 bankruptcy.
Tax Returns. The new bankruptcy law
gives the Chapter 7 Trustee (or the Judge) the right to verify
information about your income by reviewing copies of your income
tax returns. Upon request of the court, the Chapter 7 Trustee
(or the US Trustee) may request that you file a copy of your
federal tax return (or a tax transcript) for the tax year ending
during the time the case is pending and/or for the three years
prior to the filing of the petition. Income tax
refunds are property of the bankruptcy estate and will be paid
to the Chapter 7 trustee. The bankruptcy trustees in the Orlando Division require a copy of your last two tax returns prior to your trustee meetings.
OTHER THINGS THAT HAPPEN AFTER FILING
Suggestion of Bankruptcy. You should
provide a copy of any lawsuits you have received to your bankruptcy
attorney or provide a copy of the bankruptcy court's notice
of the commencement of your case to your civil attorney, so
that a Suggestion of Bankruptcy can be filed in any civil case
in which you are a party.
Relief from Stay.
In Chapter 7 bankruptcy cases secured creditors typically file
a Motion for Relief from the Automatic Stay so that they are
able to foreclose on your secured property in the event you
do not pay your secured debt in a timely manner. Relief from
stay motions are most often filed by mortgage lenders or car
finance companies. The Court will usually grant this Motion
but that does not mean that the creditor can take your property.
The creditor can take your property only if you do not pay the
loan in a timely manner under the terms of your mortgage or
loan contract with the creditor, and only after the creditor
forecloses its mortgage or lien in state court. If you
are behind in your car loan payments, however, the creditor
can repossess the vehicle once the stay is lifted.
Procedure for Stay Motions. When a
secured creditor files a Motion for Relief From Stay the court
will set a hearing. Since the court usually grants the Motion,
most bankruptcy attorneys do not attend the hearing, and in
many instances your attorney will consent to the granting of
the Motion. You do not have to attend the hearing unless you
want to contest the Motion, in which case, you should contact
your bankruptcy attorney in advance.
Transferring Property After Filing.
Immediately upon the filing of a bankruptcy petition, a legal
“estate” is created by the law which consists of
everything you own at the time you filed bankruptcy. This is
called the “bankruptcy estate.” In fact, one of
the Trustee’s principal duties is to collect the bankruptcy
estate (that is, locate and assume jurisdiction over all the
property). You should never sell, give away, or transfer any
of your real or personal property which is part of your bankruptcy
estate either immediately before or after the filing of your
petition without checking with with your bankruptcy attorney.
You may transfer or sell property you claimed as exempt property on your banrkuptcy petition if there is no objection made to the exemption within 30 days after you meet the bankruptcy trustee.
ADVERSARY MATTERS
Adversary Claim by a Creditor. The
majority of Chapter 7 cases do not involve adversary matters;
however, if a creditor believes it should not be discharged,
it may file, or threaten to file, an Adversary Case against
you during the bankruptcy proceeding. The most common grounds
for the filing an adversary case is “fraud.” Fraud
in this context is not criminal, but it means that you allegedly
have abused the bankruptcy process. For example, if you used
credit to buy property or take cash advances prior to filing
bankruptcy when you were insolvent, did not anticipate repaying
the debt, or planned to file bankruptcy, this could be grounds
to set aside a discharge of debt for fraud, and the creditor
may have a basis to file an adversary case.
Adversary Claim by Chapter 7 Trustee. The Trustee
may also file an adversary case to recover non-exempt property.
A Trustee may also file a motion to value property which he
believes you have undervalued in order to exempt under your
$1,000 personal property exemption. If the Trustee convinces
the court to increase the property value, he can then recover
any of your property in excess of your exemption limit.
Trustee's
Objection to Exemptions. The Chapter 7 bankruptcy trustee
has 30 days after the creditors meeting to object to any exemption
of property claimed on your bankruptcy petition. Absent trustee
objection, all property listed as exempt, including your homestead
exemption, is exempted in bankruptcy and is not part of your
bankruptcy estate. If the trustee objection to a claimed exemption,
the court will set a hearing to rule on your exemption. Absent
objection by the trustee all assets claimed as exempt on your
bankurptcy petition are protected. If there is no objection to your exemptions within 30 days after your creditor meeting you probably can do what you want with assets claimed as exempt on your peitition, but you should consult your bankrutcy attorney before disposing or transferring property.
Objections By U.S. Trustee: The United States Trustee's office oversees the panel of Chapter 7 trustees. The U.S. Trustee reviews most bankruptcy cases. If the U.S. Trustee believes a Chapter 7 debtor has sufficient monthly cash flow to repay a significant portion of his unsecured debts the Trustee may file an adversary complaint alleging substantial abuse of the bankruptcy law. The U.S. Trustee would request the court convert the Chapter 7 filing to a Chapter 13 case with a repayment plan. The Chapter 7 debtor can defend his Chapter 7 filing by demonstrating financial hardship and an inability to repay creditors in Chapter 13.
The Bankruptcy Discharge
60-Day Waiting Period. After the Creditors
Meeting, there is a 60-day period during which time creditors
can file claims if they believe you have non-exempt assets and
during which creditors may object to being discharged provided
they have legal grounds. Grounds for objection to discharge
include the fraud, student loans, alimony and support obligations
etc.
Discharge Order. A minimum of
60 days (usually more) following the creditors meeting you should
receive a copy of a court order that discharges your debts.
The discharge order wipes out your debts and liability to creditors
in your bankruptcy. Do not expect to receive your discharge
immediately after 60 days. You can call the Bankruptcy Voice
Case Information System at (866) 879-1286 for an update on your
case.
Discharged Debts. The entry of a discharge
order does not affect a secured creditor’s rights in property
which you pledged to repay the secured creditor. The secured
creditor can always repossess the secured property if you do
not pay according to your loan agreement. In addition, the discharge
order only discharges debts that “are dischargeable.”
Therefore, the order does not eliminate non-dischargeable debts,
such as student loans, ineligible tax liability, or loans procured
by fraud or by abuse of the bankruptcy system. The Order of
Discharge does not give you a list of specific debts that were
discharged; it simply states that dischargeable debts are discharged.
Debts Not Discharged. The Bankruptcy
Code has a list of debts which cannot be discharged in Chapter
7 bankruptcy. These non-dischargeable debts include:
• Debts incurred through fraud or embezzlement;
• Recent income tax liability;
• Education loans / student loans;
• Fines and penalties payable to the government;
• Child support, alimony, and property settlement obligations;
• Debts incurred for the purchase of luxury goods.
There is a presumption
of non-dischargeability for cash advances of over $750 taken
within seventy (70) days of filing and for purchase of more
than $500 within ninety (90) days of filing.
CLOSING YOUR CASE
Approximately 30 to 45 days after the Discharge, you will receive
another notice stating that your case is closed. This means
that your bankruptcy case is over.
LIFE
AFTER BANKRUPTCY
Bankruptcy and Your Credit Rating. Bankruptcy will appear on your credit report for several years.
This does not mean you cannot get credit after filing bankruptcy.
Most lenders will extend credit within two or three years after
filing a bankruptcy case. Many creditors consider you a better
credit risk after you filed bankruptcy because you have few
other debts, if any, and you are unable to file bankruptcy again
for seven years.
Generally, the effect of bankruptcy on your credit is not a
bankruptcy issue; it is a banking or credit issue. Most questions
concerning reestablishment of credit are best answered by people
at banks, credit agencies, or consumer credit services. Most
banks and mortgage companies state that a debtor can establish
normal credit two years after filing Chapter 7 bankruptcy.
Many debtors report that after filing bankruptcy and receiving
their discharge notice that their credit reports still show
certain debts as “written off” or “discharged.”
It may take the credit reporting agencies several months to
update your file. Regardless of what is on your credit report,
no creditor listed in your bankruptcy can collect money from
you. If your credit report incorrectly reports certain debts
you must resolve errors directly with the credit bureau because
no bankruptcy law issues are involved in the incorrect reporting
of your credit history. If you have contested the error
directly with the credit reporting agency and the creditor,
and the incorrect information is not corrected, you may want
to contact an attorney to discuss your legal rights under the
Fair Credit Reporting Act.
Bankruptcy and Employment. It is illegal
for an employer to discriminate against you in any way because
you have filed bankruptcy. Bankruptcy does not affect r professional licenses in Florida. In most cases, bankruptcy will not affect a security clearance. You are less risky to a private or government employer after your bankruptcy has alleviated your financial problems.
|
Home
| Qualifications
| Practice
Areas | Contact
Us | Legal
Disclaimer | Sitemap
Publications: Florida
Bar Journal, June 2004 | Florida
Bar Seminar, May 2003 | Florida
Bar Journal, December 1984 |
Media Recognition
Florida Bar Seminar May 2005 | National
Business Institute Seminar May 2005 | Steve
Leimberg's Asset Protection Planning Newsletter Florida Bar Health Law Handbook 2007
Asset
Protection Basics: Who
Needs It | Does
It Work? | 10
Biggest Planning Mistakes
Fraudulent
Conveyances | Liability
for Asset Protection | Debtor
Liablity | Attorney
Liability
Florida
Asset Protection: Moving
to Florida | Homestead
Protection | Statutory
Protection | Joint
Ownership
Partnerships
/ LLC | Family
Ltd. Partnerships | Florida
Residency
Offshore
Asset Protection: Offshore
Trusts | Nevis
LLCs | IRS Reporting Forms
Financial
Asset Protection: Annuities | Life Insurance | Leveraged Accounts Receivable | Business
Protection
Asset
Protection Updates: Delaware
Series LLC | Domestic
Asset Protection Trust | Equity
Stripping | Florida's New Trust Law | Mortgage Foreclosure Deficiency
Estate
Planning: Living
Trusts | Wills | Probate | Irrevocable
Trusts | Estate
Tax Basics
Bankruptcy:
Bankruptcy
FAQs | Chapter
7 | Chapter
13 | The Means Test | Involuntary
Bankruptcy
Income
Taxes and Bankruptcy | Bankruptcy
Mistakes to Avoid | Bankruptcy's
Effect on Credit | Attorneys'
Fees | Moral
Issues
Disclaimer
The hiring of an attorney is an important decision that should not be
based solely upon advertisements.
Before you decide, ask us to send you free written information about
our qualifications and experience.
Copyright © 2010 by Jonathan B. Alper. All rights
reserved.
|